Paul Scholes has expressed reservations about Manchester United's pursuit of Elliot Anderson, despite acknowledging the Nottingham Forest midfielder as a leading midfield target for the summer window. The club legend named three "realistic" signing options while warning that a rival rival club could hijack the deal.
Scholes Names Three Midfield Targets
Speaking on The Good, The Bad & The Football podcast, Scholes identified his preferred candidates to address United's midfield shortage following the departures of Manuel Ugarte and Casemiro. The three players he considers achievable acquisitions are Adam Wharton, Sandro Tonali, and Anderson—all proven Premier League operators with experience at the highest level.
Anderson has emerged as one of the division's standout performers this season and earned selection for England's squad for the upcoming European Championship. His rapid development into a box-to-box midfielder of elite quality has made him a priority for INEOS planners. However, Scholes fears the Red Devils may face competition from an unexpected quarter in their pursuit.
Manchester City Threat Looms
"The only thing I think about Elliot Anderson, I've got a feeling Manchester City might go for him," Scholes revealed. The concern carries weight given that Manchester City are preparing for life without Bernardo Silva, leaving a void in their midfield that Anderson could fill. City's proven ability to land priority targets makes them formidable competitors in any transfer race.
The comment underscores the challenge facing United's recruitment team: even identified targets carry no guarantees in a competitive market where wealthier rivals can move decisively. Anderson's profile—young, English, and capable of operating across multiple midfield roles—appeals to several top-six clubs simultaneously.
Carrick's Permanent Role Brings New Pressures
Beyond transfer strategy, Scholes highlighted concerns surrounding Michael Carrick's imminent appointment as permanent manager. While praising the interim boss for orchestrating an unexpected Champions League qualification, Scholes warned that expectations will fundamentally shift once Carrick's position becomes permanent. "This job changes now for him," Scholes stated. "It's still a big job now but now it's real, he's got trophies to go for, he's got to try and get them close to winning the league and that will come from expectation."
The transition from caretaker to permanent authority introduces fresh demands. Success against relegation-form opposition differs markedly from sustained title challenges, and Scholes's comments reflect broader questions about whether Carrick's short-term improvements can translate into long-term silverware. United's midfield recruitment this summer will prove crucial to answering that question.
